Game design isn’t often decided by democracy. Sure, the new Torment game’s combat will be turn-based because backers voted as such, but that’s the exception - games are made by teams, and teams need direction.
UK indies Cardboard Sword, however, have found a way to satisfy everyone. They only had to invent a new genre to do it.
“In our planning meetings some of the team voted Metroidvania as a base and some voted stealth, another team favourite,” says managing director Olly Bennett. “Combining the two has not been done before to our knowledge.”
The Siege and the Sandfox is a Steathvania adventure, then - the first of its kind. As a thief caught padding around a royal palace, you’re falsely accused of regicide and thrown into the dungeons.
In escaping you come to know its cavernous, sandy ruins, bypassing prison guards and possessed sand immortals in pursuit of power-ups to your abilities. As in any ‘vania worth its salt, new abilities in The Siege and the Sandfox unlock areas previously blocked by your own inexperience.
“I own about four SNES carts of Super Metroid alone,” explains Bennett, “and between us we’ve played everything from Castlevania: Symphony of the Night to Guacamelee to Axiom Verge.”
How does one go about combining that tradition with tricksy stealth? Cardboard Sword plan to strip the genre of on-screen minimaps and awareness indicators and leave players only with the behaviour and body language of their enemies.
“We want them to be a real threat,” says Bennett. “You won’t always be able to pick them off one at a time until the threat is gone; there are very limited and infrequent ways to remove an enemy from the equation.”
Instead you’ll be evading. Line of sight will matter but so too will audio, with different surface materials and movement speed affecting what sort of racket you make. Your thief can jump far and high, running up and off walls and swinging on poles.
“Imagine a parkour Flashback with the rhythm of Mirror’s Edge,” suggests Bennett.
Mark of the Ninja is a touchpoint for flattening stealth onto a single plane without losing its nuance, while the team are equally fond of Looking Glass’ Thief games for their logical level design.
“The maps were laid out in a way that would make sense from the enemy perspective and then adapted for gameplay, rather than the other way around,” remembers Bennett. “It would make you think, ‘If I was making a guard tower to defend myself, how would I do it?’.”
Cardboard Sword intend for The Siege and the Sandfox’s environments to allow for multiple, emergent routes, and above all to feel real. To that end, it helps that the project has coalesced around an alluringly dense and gothic art style.
The team’s two artists, Ed and Keith Duke-Cox, created the world of The Siege and the Sandfox as a hobby project and unveiled it to the studio soon after joining up. Their work became the canon that the team - made up largely of Frontier Developments and Little Big Planet Vita veterans - wrote and designed around.
“A lot of pixel art games go for vibrant colours and sometimes don’t maintain a single resolution and ratio,” says Bennett. “We wanted our art to create something deeper and darker, with a real sense of depth to everything.”
The Duke-Cox’s fantasy kingdom draws architectural inspiration from various cultures and points in history, but there’s a touch of Prince of Persia about its tall windows and torchlit stone corridors, and more than a grain of Indiana Jones and Uncharted in its dusty depths.
“It was important to us to evoke the kind of visuals you find in the 16-bit era, as we feel the 8-bit style has been very well explored in recent years,” Bennett adds. “We wanted to not just emulate a nostalgic style, but extend it with modern tools and technology.”
Cardboard Sword have exploited the visual effects potential of Unreal Engine 4, which they picked to take advantage of the team’s existing skills.
“There is a prevailing assumption that UE4 is unsuitable for 2D development, but after starting the project with Unreal we found this to be false,” says Bennett. “Many of the tools, like Blueprints or the existing lighting, worked practically straight out of the box to produce many of the results you can already see in our game.”
The studio are now working with Talespinners, an outsource writing outfit who contributed to SOMA and Frozen Synapse Prime, on a story and informal quest structure for their sprawling dungeon. Beyond that, they’re looking for a publisher.
Cardboard Sword can’t always make everyone happy. Often democracy finds them disagreeing, each fighting their own corners, before choosing the most reasoned perspective on how to proceed. Something they can all agree on, though, is the intense artistry of their gothic palace.
“Sorry to harp on about it,” Bennett apologises. “But the pixel work of Ed and Keith is so pretty.”
Find out more on The Siege and the Sandfox's official site.
Editor's Note: PCGamesN selects fantastic Unreal Engine games and interviews developers of their choosing for the long-running "Making It in Unreal" series. Epic has no influence on the editorial process.